Pictured: Several Goldfish plushes from my collection. Not pictured: Vintage Goldfish Pillow, Jumbo Goldfish Witch.
A list of Goldfish plushes released over the years.
Released: 70s/80s?
This is your standard size pillow resembling a Goldfish. It has furrowed eyebrows. (Note that back in the olden days, Goldfish were depicted with eyebrows, but from the 90s onward they have mostly been depicted without eyebrows.)
Released: Circa March/April 1999
The Goldfish Beanbag Bunny was likely produced to capitalize on the beanbag plush craze of the mid-to-late 90s. It was given out to people who purchased enough of specific Pepperidge Farm products. It is only a few inches long and wears a bunny ears headband. Manufactured by A. Aronson inc.
Released: Circa March 1999
This plush was most likely not given out to the public, but rather used as a display piece in stores used to sell Goldfish products. It is about 6 times larger than the beanbag version, measuring about 3 feet long. Manufactured by A. Aronson inc.
Released: Circa October 1999
This plush, like the Goldfish Beanbag Bunny, was given out to people who purchased Pepperidge Farm products. It is identical to the Bunny except for wearing a witch’s hat instead of a bunny headband. Manufactured by A. Aronson inc.
Released: Circa October 1999
This plush is identical to the Jumbo Goldfish Bunny in appearance and function, except for the witch hat. Manufactured by A. Aronson inc.
Released: 2001 - 2002
This plush is similar in size to the Goldfish beanbags. It features Boomer with his signature sunglasses. Four plush wheels (not real ones) are stitched to the bottom of him, making the plush resemble the Goldfish Mobile. It was most likely sold at the "Miles of Smiles" tour that ran from 2001 to 2002. Manufactured by Sterling Promotional Corp.
Released: 2004
This pillow of Boomer is slightly over a foot long. Boomer’s sunglasses are stitched unusually high on his head compared to where his eyes should be. The tush tag has a 2004 copyright notice. Manufactured by Creative Kids International inc.